It was the Bulky Asymmetrical Cardigan by Knitting Pure and Simple that I chose for car knitting on the drive home. Being bulky - well, chunky really - it knits up very quickly. One and a bit sleeve to go and it's done.
But there are issues. The front neck is Very Low. Not that I didn't see that in the picture, but sadly, seeing and registering are often two different things. It has occurred to me that bulky being bulky, Asymmetrical probably won't be an indoor sweater. But with that very low neckline, it won't be the best outdoor sweater either. That openness could be stuffed with a scarf I suppose, but I'm not sure I want to mar the simplicity of the design by stuffing the top with a scarf. I can't quite envision it.
Then there is the issue of button/hole placement. In the picture I've put markers where the buttons will go. Looks fine, lying flat. But on me and my short frame, the 'buttons' seem to end too low on the sweater to truly replicate the beauty of the 'three-buttons-at-the-top' design. Shortening the sweater from the suggested 25 1/2" to my standard 'long-sweater' length of 23 inches obviously shortened the distance between buttons and bottom. No such luck that I might have realized the shorter length would require shortening the distance between buttonholes. Dang! Ripping back to above the sleeve join to redo the buttonholes doesn't appeal to me. I am considering stitching the button holes closed and using a pin. Could work.
Then - point three - there is the flaring/swinging bottom. The sweater has normal, waist shaping - decreases above the waistline, increases below it. Those increased hip stitches, done in chunky yarn, in seed stitch, falling exactly at my widest point? Not pretty. After all - bulky means bulky.
There will be ripping. And a note to my knitting file - no more sweaters in thick yarn.